CRITICAL NOTE · No. 09

Empty the Cup

On unlearning what you know in order to learn what you don’t

The parable of the philosopher and the cup of tea is worth recalling. A student visiting a thinker asks him interminable questions — but each time, unconsciously, he answers them himself first, in his own head, from his own existing frame. The master pours tea into the student’s cup, and keeps pouring after it is full, until it overflows. You cannot fill a cup that is already full.

To learn a new system — a combat art, a way of moving, a logic of the body — you must first set down the schemas built over years. Otherwise the new is only ever received as a variation of the old, filtered, distorted, never grasped on its own terms. The expert’s knowledge becomes the very obstacle to his learning.

This is why beginners sometimes progress faster than seasoned practitioners crossing into a new discipline: they have less to unlearn. To empty the cup is not to become ignorant — it is the hardest discipline of the accomplished, the willingness to be a beginner again, to suspend the reflex to explain the new by the known. Only the emptied cup can be filled.

RELATED NOTES

→ One Game, a Whole World of Movement

→ I Discovered Capoeira Through a Van Damme Film

IN THE CORPUS

→ Capoeira Is Not Alone in the World

→ Black Combat Arts: What They Are